diff --git a/app/Controllers/Notifications.php b/app/Controllers/Notifications.php
index b74d2919..ea329d58 100755
--- a/app/Controllers/Notifications.php
+++ b/app/Controllers/Notifications.php
@@ -800,19 +800,19 @@ class Notifications extends BaseController
                 echo "Notification Campaign Name = ".$single_campaign['campaign_name']."<br>";
                 #step 2 get template details
                 $template = $this->getTemplateDetails($single_campaign['template_id']);
+                $customer_details = $this->getCustomerDetails($single_campaign['group_id']);
                 $this->logger->error("Auto Scheduled Template Details TID = ".$single_campaign['template_id']);
-                if(count($template))
+                if(count($template) && count($customer_details))
                 {
-                    #step 2.1
-                    $history_parents_data = ['campaign_id' => $single_campaign['campaign_id'],'status' => 0];
-                    $history_parent_id = $model->save_notification_history_parents($history_parents_data);
-                    $single_campaign['history_parent_id'] = $history_parent_id;
-
                     #step 3 execute the customer group query and return customer details 
-                    $customer_details = $this->getCustomerDetails($single_campaign['group_id']);
                     $sent_customer_details = [];
                     if(count($customer_details))
                     {
+                        #step 2.1
+                        $history_parents_data = ['campaign_id' => $single_campaign['campaign_id'],'status' => 0];
+                        $history_parent_id = $model->save_notification_history_parents($history_parents_data);
+                        $single_campaign['history_parent_id'] = $history_parent_id;
+                   
                         foreach($customer_details as $customer)
                         {
                            
@@ -861,7 +861,7 @@ class Notifications extends BaseController
                                     $this->logger->error($history_child_statement);
 
                                 }
-                                else
+                                if($single_campaign['mode'] == 'Whatsapp')
                                 {
                                     $params = (object) Null;
                                     $url = SEND_WAAI_URL;
@@ -886,22 +886,19 @@ class Notifications extends BaseController
                             }
                         }
                     }
-                }
+                    // #step 6 update campaign status to 1
+                    $statement = $model->update_notification_campaign_status(['status' => 1],$single_campaign['campaign_id']);
+                    echo "Final Campaign Status  = ".$statement."<br>";
+                    $this->logger->error($statement);
 
-                #step 6 update campaign status to 1
-                $statement = $model->update_notification_campaign_status(['status' => 1],$single_campaign['campaign_id']);
-                echo "Final Campaign Status  = ".$statement."<br>";
-                $this->logger->error($statement);
+                    #step 7 update history parent status to 1
+                    $history_parent_statement = $model->update_notification_history_parent_status(['status' => 1],$history_parent_id,$single_campaign['campaign_id']);
+                    echo "Final Acknowlegdement  = ".$history_parent_statement."<br>";
+                    $this->logger->error($history_parent_statement);
 
-                #step 7 update history parent status to 1
-                $history_parent_statement = $model->update_notification_history_parent_status(['status' => 1],$single_campaign['history_parent_id'],$single_campaign['campaign_id']);
-                echo "Final Acknowlegdement  = ".$history_parent_statement."<br>";
-                $this->logger->error($history_parent_statement);
-
-            }
-            
-        }
-        
+                }     
+            }        
+        }     
     }
 
     #step 1 get scheduled notification details