diff --git a/app/Config/Routes.php b/app/Config/Routes.php
index ebfe2a84..379713d4 100755
--- a/app/Config/Routes.php
+++ b/app/Config/Routes.php
@@ -158,7 +158,7 @@ $routes->match(['get','post'],'/itemwise_report_with_payment_method','Invoice::i
 # Notifications Routes
 // $routes->get('controller/SubExpdetail/(:num)', 'YourController::SubExpdetail/$1');
 
-$routes->get("getExpCustomerDetail/(:num)",'Notifications::getExpCustomerDetail/$1');
+$routes->get("getExpCustomerDetail/(:any)",'Notifications::getExpCustomerDetail/$1');
 $routes->get('send_whatsapp_message/', 'Notifications::send_whatsapp_message');
 // $routes->post('whatsapp_custom_notifications/', 'Notifications::whatsapp_custom_notifications');
 // $routes->match(['post', 'get'], 'mail_custom_notifications', 'Notifications::mail_custom_notifications');
diff --git a/app/Controllers/Notifications.php b/app/Controllers/Notifications.php
index f1a24640..dbc5dbe0 100755
--- a/app/Controllers/Notifications.php
+++ b/app/Controllers/Notifications.php
@@ -572,11 +572,14 @@ class Notifications extends BaseController
     public function getExpCustomerDetail($window_time = null)
     {
         $this->update_expired_members();
-        $response = "<pre> Hi, ";
+        $response ="<pre>";// $response = "<pre> Hi, Started. <br>";
         #  Step 1: add the days to retrive the data//
         $providedDate = date('Y-m-d');
-        $newDate = date('Y-m-d', strtotime($providedDate . ' + ' . $window_time . ' days'));
-        $this->logger->error('EXPIRYDATE  T-Date = '.$providedDate.', Given ' .$window_time.' Day, Calacuated Date based on Given day count = '.$newDate);
+        if($window_time >= 0){
+            $newDate = date('Y-m-d', strtotime("$providedDate + $window_time days"));
+        }else{
+            $newDate = date('Y-m-d', strtotime("$providedDate $window_time days"));
+        }
 
         #  Step 2 :Get the customer detail//
         $NotificationModel = new NotificationModel();
@@ -596,125 +599,90 @@ class Notifications extends BaseController
         }
         $db = \Config\Database::connect();
         $queryResult = $db->query($modifiedQuery)->getResultArray();
-        
 
         $notification = new NotificationHelper();
         if (empty($queryResult)) {
             $this->logger->error("There is no customer expiring on date:{$newDate}");
-            $response .= " There is no customer expiring. till dated :{$newDate}";
-            return;
+            $response .= "There is no customer expiring. Date = ".date('d/m/Y', strtotime($newDate))." </pre>";
+            return $this->response->setBody($response);
         }
        
         $emailTemplateName = $NotificationModel->getTempName('EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE EMAIL');
-        $response .= "Started.<br> Customer expiring. till dated = ".date('d/m/Y', strtotime($newDate))." <br> There are ".count($queryResult)." persons <br>";
+        $this->logger->error("Customer expiring. till {$newDate} There are ".count($queryResult)." persons");
+        $response .= "Customer expiring list. ( Date = ".date('d/m/Y', strtotime($newDate))." )<br>There are ".count($queryResult)." persons <br>";
         if(!empty($queryResult)){
             usort($queryResult, function ($a, $b) {
                 return $a['to_subscription'] <=> $b['to_subscription']; //Asc order
             });
         }
+        
         foreach ($queryResult as $inx => $row) {
             $subscription_id = $row['sub_id'];
             $status = $row['status'];
-            $userFirstName = $row['first_name'];
-            $userLastName = $row['last_name'];
-            $fullName = $userFirstName . ' ' . $userLastName;
+            $fullName = trim($row['first_name'] . ' ' . $row['last_name']);
             $userMobileNumber = $row['mobile_no'];
+            $email = $row['email'];
             $schemename = $row['title'];
             $expirydate = $row['to_subscription'];
             $customerId = $row['customer_id'];
-            $countdays = $row['countdays'];
             $membership_id = $row['membership_id'];
+            $countdays = $row['countdays'];
+            
             if (empty($fullName)) {
-                $this->logger->error('There is no subcription Name');
+                $this->logger->error('No subscription name found for record #' . $inx);
                 continue;
-            } 
-            $response .= ($inx+1).") #".$customerId." - Person Name : ".$fullName."   ----- ( Expiry on ". date('d/m/Y', strtotime($expirydate)).")  <br>";
-            if ($status === 'Approved') {
-                # EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE EMAIL
-                $emailTemplateName = $NotificationModel->getTempName('EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE EMAIL');
-                if(empty($row['email'])){
-                    $response .= ($inx+1).") Email Not Available <br>";
-                    continue;
-                }
+            }
             
-                $existingcheck = $NotificationModel->checkEmailAlreadyExisting($row['email'],$customerId);        
-                $check_existing = 0; 
-                $check_date = "";
-                $check_diff_days = "";
+            $response .= ($inx + 1) . ") #{$customerId} - Person Name = {$fullName} / {$membership_id} --- (Expiry on " . date('d/m/Y', strtotime($expirydate)) . ")<br>";
+        
+            // Skip records with non-approved status
+            if ($status !== 'Approved') {
+                $response .= ($inx + 1) . ") Status = {$status}<br>";
+                $this->logger->error("Record #{$inx}: status is not Approved");
+                continue;
+            }
+        
+            // Email Notification
+            $emailTemplateName = $NotificationModel->getTempName('EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE EMAIL');
             
-                if(!empty($existingcheck)){
-
-                    foreach ($existingcheck as $i => $r) {
-                        if($r['receiving_status'] == 1){
-                            $check_existing = 1;
-                            $check_date = $r['sent_time'];
-                            $sentTimestamp = strtotime($r['sent_time']);
-                            $provedTimestamp = strtotime($providedDate);
-
-                            
-                            $diffInSeconds = abs($provedTimestamp - $sentTimestamp);
-                            $diffInDays = $diffInSeconds / (60 * 60 * 24);
-
-                            $check_diff_days = $diffInDays; 
-                        }
-                    }
-                }
-
-                if($check_existing){
-                    $response .= ($inx+1).") Email already send on - ".date('d/m/Y h:i A', strtotime($check_date))."<br>";
-                    continue;
-                }
-
-                if (count($emailTemplateName) && !empty($emailTemplateName)) {
+            if (!empty($emailTemplateName)) {
+                $existingEmailCheck = $NotificationModel->checkAlreadyExistingInHistory($email, $customerId, $subscription_id);
+                if (empty($existingEmailCheck)) {
                     $campaign_id = 1;
                     # Insertion on History Email Means Campaign ID 1 Hardcoded
                     $history_parents_data = ['campaign_id' => $campaign_id,'status' => 0];
                     $history_parent_id = $NotificationModel->save_notification_history_parents($history_parents_data);
 
-                    # Step 4: Prepare email content based on the template
                     $emailContent = $emailTemplateName[0]['message'];
-                    if (isset($fullName)) {
-                        $emailContent = str_replace("{USER_NAME}", $fullName, $emailContent);
-                    }
-                    if (isset($schemename)) {
-                        $emailContent = str_replace("{SCHEME_NAME}", $schemename,  $emailContent);
-                    }
-                    if (isset($expirydate)) {
-                        $expiryon = $expirydate ? date('d-m-Y', strtotime($expirydate)) : '';
-                        $emailContent = str_replace("{EXPIRY_DATE}", $expiryon, $emailContent);
-                        $replaceContent = (int)$countdays == 0 ? 'expires today, ' : 'expiring on ';            
-                        $emailContent = str_replace("expiring on", $replaceContent, $emailContent);
-                    }
-                    if (isset($membership_id)) {
-                        $link = base_url() . 'subscription_renewal/' . $membership_id;
-                        $emailContent = str_replace("{RENEWAL_LINK}", '<a href="'.$link.'" target="blank" >'.$link.'</a>', $emailContent);
-                    }
-                    
-
-                
+                    $emailContent = str_replace(
+                        ['{USER_NAME}', '{SCHEME_NAME}', '{EXPIRY_DATE}', '{RENEWAL_LINK}'],
+                        [
+                            $fullName,
+                            $schemename,
+                            date('d-m-Y', strtotime($expirydate)),
+                            '<a href="' . base_url() . 'subscription_renewal/' . $membership_id . '" target="blank">' . base_url() . 'subscription_renewal/' . $membership_id . '</a>',
+                        ],
+                        $emailContent
+                    );
+        
                     $emailData = [
                         'template_name' => 'EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE EMAIL',
-                        'recipient_email' => $row['email'],
+                        'recipient_email' => $email,
                         'subject' => 'Your Subscription Expiry Notification',
                         'description' => $emailContent,
                     ];
-                    
-
                     $history_child_data = [ 'fkid' => $history_parent_id,
                                             'customer_id' => $customerId,
-                                            'receiving_entity' => $row['email'],
+                                            'receiving_entity' => $email,
                                             'receiving_status' => 0,
                                             'subscription_id' => $subscription_id,
                                             'message' => $emailContent];
-                    # Step 5: Insertion on History Child
+                  
                     $history_child_id = $NotificationModel->save_notification_history_child($history_child_data);
-
-                    # Step 6:Send email using NotificationHelper
+        
                     $emailResult = $notification->sendEmail($emailData);
-                    
-                    $this->logger->error("EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE EMAIL Email CID = ".$customerId." ".json_encode($emailResult));      
-                    
-                    if (isset($emailResult['success'])) {    
+        
+                    if (isset($emailResult['success']) && !empty($emailResult['success'])) {    
                         $history_msg = 'Email sent successfully';
                         $history_child_updatedata = ['receiving_status'=>1,'result'=>$history_msg];
                         $history_child_where = ['fkid' => $history_parent_id,'id' => (int)$history_child_id];    
@@ -736,142 +704,107 @@ class Notifications extends BaseController
                         $response .= ($inx+1).") Failed to send email <br>";
                     }
                 } else {
-                    $history_msg = 'There is no email template found by the name of EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE EMAIL';
-                    // $receiving_status =  0 ;
-                    $this->logger->error($history_msg);
-                    $response .= $history_msg."<br>";
-                    continue;
-                }
-            }
-            else{
-                $response .= ($inx+1).") Staus = ".$status." <br>";
-                $this->logger->error("status is Draft");
-            }
-            # EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE EMAIL Closed    
-            if ($status === 'Approved') {
-                $existingcheck2 = $NotificationModel->checkEmailAlreadyExisting($userMobileNumber,$customerId);        
-                $check_existing2 = 0; 
-                $check_date2 = "";
-                $check_diff_days2 = "";                
-                if(!empty($existingcheck2)){
-    
-                    foreach ($existingcheck2 as $i2 => $r2) {
-                        if($r2['receiving_status'] == 1){
-                            $check_existing2 = 1;
-                            $check_date2 = $r2['sent_time'];
-                            $sentTimestamp2 = strtotime($r2['sent_time']);
-                            $provedTimestamp2 = strtotime($providedDate);
-    
-                            
-                            $diffInSeconds2 = abs($provedTimestamp2 - $sentTimestamp2);
-                            $diffInDays2 = $diffInSeconds2 / (60 * 60 * 24);
-    
-                            $check_diff_days2 = $diffInDays2; 
-                        }
+                $check_existing = 0; 
+                $check_email_date = "";
+                
+            
+                if(!empty($existingEmailCheck)){
+
+                    foreach ($existingEmailCheck as $i => $r) {
+                        $check_email_date = ($r['receiving_status'] == 1) ? $r['sent_time'] : "";
                     }
                 }
-                if($check_existing2){
-                    $response .= ($inx+1).") whatsapp already send ".$check_date2."<br>";
-                    continue;
+                    if($check_email_date){
+                        $response .= ($inx+1).") Email already send on - ".date('d/m/Y h:i A', strtotime($check_email_date))."<br>";
+                        $this->logger->error(($inx + 1) . ") Email already sent to {$email}");
+                        $this->logger->error(($inx + 1) . ") Email already sent on {$check_email_date}");
+                    }
+
                 }
-                    # EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP
-                    $whatsappTemplateName = $NotificationModel->getTempName('EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP');
-                    // print_r($whatsappTemplateName);die;
-                    if ((count($whatsappTemplateName) > 0) && !empty($whatsappTemplateName)) {
-                        $campaign_id = 2; // hardcoded because static Template.
-                        $history_parents_data = ['campaign_id' => 2,'status' => 0];
-                        $history_parent_id = $NotificationModel->save_notification_history_parents($history_parents_data);
-                        if (empty($userMobileNumber)) {
-                            $history_msg = 'There is no subscriber mobile number';
-                            $history_child_updatedata = ['receiving_status'=>0,'result'=>$history_msg];
-                            $history_child_where = ['fkid' => $history_parent_id,'id' => (int)$history_child_id];    
-                            $history_child_statement = $NotificationModel->update_notification_history_child($history_child_updatedata,$history_child_where);
-                            $this->logger->error($history_child_statement);
+            } else {
+                $response .= ($inx + 1) . ") No email template found<br>";
+                $this->logger->error(($inx + 1) . ") No email template found<br>");
+            }
+        
+            // WhatsApp Notification
+            $whatsappTemplateName = $NotificationModel->getTempName('EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP');
+            if (!empty($whatsappTemplateName)) {
+                $existingWhatsAppCheck = $NotificationModel->checkAlreadyExistingInHistory($userMobileNumber, $customerId, $subscription_id);
+        
+                if (empty($existingWhatsAppCheck)) {
+                    
+                    $campaign_id = 2;
+                    $history_parents_data = ['campaign_id' => $campaign_id,'status' => 0];
+                    $history_parent_id = $NotificationModel->save_notification_history_parents($history_parents_data);
 
-                            $history_parent_statement = $NotificationModel->update_notification_history_parent_status(['status' => 1],$history_parent_id,$campaign_id);
-                            $this->logger->error($history_parent_statement);
-                            $this->logger->error($history_msg);
-                            $response .= ($inx+1).") ".$history_msg."<br>";
-                            continue;
-                        }
-                        # Insertion on History Whatsapp Means Campaign ID 2 Hardcoded
-                        $history_parents_data = ['campaign_id' => 2,'status' => 0];
-                        $history_parent_id = $NotificationModel->save_notification_history_parents($history_parents_data);
+                    $whatsappContent = $whatsappTemplateName[0]['message'];
+                    $whatsappContent = str_replace(
+                        ['{USER_NAME}', '{SCHEME_NAME}', '{EXPIRY_DATE}', '{RENEWAL_LINK}'],
+                        [
+                            $fullName,
+                            $schemename,
+                            date('d-m-Y', strtotime($expirydate)),
+                            base_url() . 'subscription_renewal/' . $customerId,
+                        ],
+                        $whatsappContent
+                    );
+        
+                    $params = (object)[
+                        'number' => '91' . $userMobileNumber,
+                        'type' => 'text',
+                        'message' => $whatsappContent,
+                        'instance_id' => $_ENV['WAAI_INSTANCE'],
+                        'access_token' => $_ENV['WAAI_TOKEN'],
+                    ];
+        
+                    $whatsappResult = $notification->sendWhatsAppMessage(SEND_WAAI_URL, "POST", $params);
+                    $history_child_data = [ 'fkid' => $history_parent_id,
+                    'customer_id' => $customerId,
+                    'receiving_entity' => $userMobileNumber,
+                    'receiving_status' => 0,
+                    'subscription_id' => $subscription_id,
+                    'message' => strip_tags(ltrim($whatsappContent))];
+                    $history_child_id = $NotificationModel->save_notification_history_child($history_child_data);
+                    $receiving_status = $whatsappResult['receiving_status'];
+                    $history_msg = strtolower(gettype($whatsappResult)) == "string" ? $whatsappResult : json_encode($whatsappResult['reponse']);
+                    $history_child_updatedata = ['receiving_status'=>$receiving_status,'result'=>$history_msg];
+                    $history_child_where = ['fkid' => $history_parent_id,'id' => (int)$history_child_id];    
+                    $history_child_statement = $NotificationModel->update_notification_history_child($history_child_updatedata,$history_child_where);
+                    $this->logger->error($history_child_statement);
 
-                        # Step 7: Prepare whatsapp content based on the template
-                        $whatsappContent = $whatsappTemplateName[0]['message'];
-                        if (isset($fullName)) {
-                            $whatsappContent = str_replace("{USER_NAME}", $fullName, $whatsappContent);
+                    $history_parent_statement = $NotificationModel->update_notification_history_parent_status(['status' => 1],$history_parent_id,$campaign_id);
+                    $this->logger->error($history_parent_statement);
+                    if(strtolower(gettype($whatsappResult)) == "string"){
+                        $response .= ($inx+1).") ".$whatsappResult."<br>";
+                    }
+                    else{
+                        $result = json_encode($whatsappResult['reponse']);
+                        $decodedResult = json_decode($result, true);
+                        if ($decodedResult && isset($decodedResult['message']['key']['remoteJid'])) {
+                            $remoteJid = $decodedResult['message']['key']['remoteJid'];
+                            $this->logger->error("EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP Remote Jid = " . $remoteJid);
+                            $response .= ($inx+1).") Whatsapp sent successfully <br>";
+                        } else {
+                            // echo "Failed to extract remoteJid";
+                            $this->logger->error("EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP Failed to extract remoteJid ");
+                            $response .= ($inx+1).") Failed to send Whatsapp <br>";
                         }
-                        if (isset($schemename)) {
-                            $whatsappContent = str_replace("{SCHEME_NAME}", $schemename,  $whatsappContent);
+                    }
+                } else {
+                    $check_whatsapp_date = "";
+                    if(!empty($existingWhatsAppCheck)){
+                        foreach ($existingWhatsAppCheck as $i => $r) {
+                            $check_whatsapp_date = ($r['receiving_status'] == 1) ? $r['sent_time'] : "";
                         }
-                        if (isset($expirydate)) {
-                            $expiryon = $expirydate ? date('d-m-Y', strtotime($expirydate)) : '';
-                            $whatsappContent = str_replace("{EXPIRY_DATE}", $expiryon, $whatsappContent);
-                        }
-                        if (isset($customerId)) {
-                            $whatsappContent = str_replace("{RENEWAL_LINK}", base_url() . 'subscription_renewal/' . $customerId, $whatsappContent);
-                        }
-                        # Step 8: Insertion on History Child for whatsapp
-                        $history_child_data = [ 'fkid' => $history_parent_id,
-                        'customer_id' => $customerId,
-                        'receiving_entity' => $userMobileNumber,
-                        'receiving_status' => 0,
-                        'subscription_id' => $subscription_id,
-                        'message' => strip_tags(ltrim($whatsappContent))];
-                        $history_child_id = $NotificationModel->save_notification_history_child($history_child_data);
-
-
-                        # Step 8: Send Whatsapp using NotificationHelper
-                        $params = (object) Null;
-                        $url = SEND_WAAI_URL;
-                        $params->number = (int)'91' . $userMobileNumber;
-                        $params->type = "text";
-                        $params->message = strip_tags(ltrim($whatsappContent));
-                        $params->instance_id = $_ENV['WAAI_INSTANCE'];
-                        $params->access_token = $_ENV['WAAI_TOKEN'];
-                        $this->logger->error("EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP Request = " . json_encode($params));
-                        $this->logger->error("EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP Request type b4 = " . gettype($params));
-                        $whatsapp_result = $notification->sendWhatsAppMessage($url, "POST", $params);
-                        $receiving_status = $whatsapp_result['receiving_status'];
-                        $history_msg = strtolower(gettype($whatsapp_result)) == "string" ? $whatsapp_result : json_encode($whatsapp_result['reponse']);
-                        $history_child_updatedata = ['receiving_status'=>$receiving_status,'result'=>$history_msg];
-                        $history_child_where = ['fkid' => $history_parent_id,'id' => (int)$history_child_id];    
-                        $history_child_statement = $NotificationModel->update_notification_history_child($history_child_updatedata,$history_child_where);
-                        $this->logger->error($history_child_statement);
-
-                        $history_parent_statement = $NotificationModel->update_notification_history_parent_status(['status' => 1],$history_parent_id,$campaign_id);
-                        $this->logger->error($history_parent_statement);
-                        $this->logger->error("EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP Reponse = " . $history_msg);
-
-                        if(strtolower(gettype($whatsapp_result)) == "string"){
-                            $response .= ($inx+1).") ".$whatsapp_result."<br>";
-                        }
-                        else{
-                            $result = json_encode($whatsapp_result['reponse']);
-                            $decodedResult = json_decode($result, true);
-                            if ($decodedResult && isset($decodedResult['message']['key']['remoteJid'])) {
-                                $remoteJid = $decodedResult['message']['key']['remoteJid'];
-                                $this->logger->error("EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP Remote Jid = " . $remoteJid);
-                                $response .= ($inx+1).") Whatsapp sent successfully <br>";
-                            } else {
-                                // echo "Failed to extract remoteJid";
-                                $this->logger->error("EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP Failed to extract remoteJid ");
-                                $response .= ($inx+1).") Failed to send Whatsapp <br>";
-                            }
-                        }
-                    } else {
-                        // $receiving_status = 0;
-                        $history_msg = 'There is no Whatsapp template found by the name of EXPIRAY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP ';
-                        $this->logger->error($history_msg);
-                        $response .= "There is no Whatsapp template <br>";
-                        continue;
-                    }           
-                    # EXPIRY NOTIFY TEMPLATE WHATSAPP Closed
-            } 
-            else{
-                $this->logger->error("status is draft");
+                    }
+                    if($check_whatsapp_date){
+                        $response .= ($inx+1).") WhatsApp already send on - ".date('d/m/Y h:i A', strtotime($check_whatsapp_date))."<br>";
+                        $this->logger->error(($inx + 1) . ") WhatsApp already sent to {$userMobileNumber}");
+                        $this->logger->error(($inx + 1) . ") WhatsApp already sent on {$check_whatsapp_date}");
+                    }
+                }
+            } else {
+                $response .= ($inx + 1) . ") No WhatsApp template found<br>";
             }
         # Loop Closed
         }
diff --git a/app/Models/HomeModel.php b/app/Models/HomeModel.php
index 01930699..d09bee6a 100755
--- a/app/Models/HomeModel.php
+++ b/app/Models/HomeModel.php
@@ -104,6 +104,7 @@ class HomeModel extends Model
         $query = $this->db->table('subscription AS S')
             ->select('S.business_id, BK.title as name, BK.short_code, BK.book_id as id, S.scheme_id, LEFT(BK.title, 1) AS first_letter, COUNT(S.customer_id) AS count, BI.wp_img_url')
             ->select('COUNT(S.customer_id) AS overall, COUNT(IF(S.isactive = 1, S.customer_id, NULL)) AS activeoverall, COUNT(IF(S.is_renew = 0 AND S.isactive = 1, S.customer_id, NULL)) AS nonrenewal, COUNT(IF(S.is_renew = 1 AND S.isactive = 1, S.customer_id, NULL)) AS renewal, SUM(CASE WHEN S.created_on >= NOW() - INTERVAL 30 DAY THEN 1 ELSE 0 END) AS new_subscribers')
+            ->select('COUNT(IF(S.status = 1, S.customer_id, NULL)) AS active,COUNT(IF(S.status = 0, S.customer_id, NULL)) AS expired,COUNT(IF(S.is_renew > 0  AND S.status = 1, S.customer_id, NULL)) AS renew')
             ->join('customers AS C', 'C.customer_id = S.customer_id AND C.isactive = 1', 'left')
             ->join('books AS BK', 'BK.book_id = S.scheme_id', 'left')
             ->join('book_categories AS BC', 'BC.book_id = S.scheme_id AND BC.isactive = 1', 'left')
@@ -185,29 +186,15 @@ class HomeModel extends Model
             ->join('books as BK', 'BK.book_id = S.scheme_id', 'left')
             ->join('book_categories as BC', 'BC.book_id = S.scheme_id', 'left')
             ->join('category as CM', 'CM.id = BC.category_id', 'left')
+            ->join('notification_history_children as NHC', 'NHC.subscription_id = S.sub_id AND NHC.receiving_status = 1 AND NHC.receiving_entity LIKE "%@%"', 'left')
+            ->join('notification_history_parents as NHP', 'NHP.id = NHC.fkid', 'left')
             ->select('CM.name, CONCAT_WS(" ", C.first_name, C.last_name) as customer_name, 
                       C.email as customer_email, C.mobile_no as customer_mobile, 
                       S.sub_id, S.scheme_id, S.customer_id, S.business_id, 
-                      S.to_subscription, S.from_subscription, BK.title, BK.short_code, BK.book_id, 
+                      S.to_subscription, S.from_subscription, BK.title, BK.short_code, BK.book_id, S.membership_id,
                       DATEDIFF(S.to_subscription, CURDATE()) as countdays, 
                       DATE_FORMAT(S.to_subscription, "%d/%m/%Y") as to_subscription_date_format,
-                      (
-                        SELECT MAX(NHP.start_date_time)
-                        FROM notification_campaign as NC
-                        LEFT JOIN notification_history_parents as NHP ON NHP.campaign_id = NC.campaign_id
-                        LEFT JOIN notification_history_children as NHC ON NHC.fkid = NHP.id
-                        WHERE NHC.customer_id = C.customer_id AND NHC.receiving_entity LIKE "%@%" AND NHC.receiving_status = 1
-                        AND NHP.start_date_time >= DATE_SUB(CURDATE(), INTERVAL 30 DAY)
-                      ) as email_last_notify_on,
-                      (
-                        SELECT MAX(NHP.start_date_time)
-                        FROM notification_campaign as NC
-                        LEFT JOIN notification_history_parents as NHP ON NHP.campaign_id = NC.campaign_id
-                        LEFT JOIN notification_history_children as NHC ON NHC.fkid = NHP.id
-                        WHERE NHC.customer_id = S.customer_id AND NHC.receiving_entity NOT LIKE "%@%" AND NHC.receiving_status = 1
-                          AND NHC.receiving_status REGEXP "^[0-9]+$"
-                          AND NHP.start_date_time >= DATE_SUB(CURDATE(), INTERVAL 30 DAY)
-                      ) as whatsapp_last_notify_on')
+                      ( NHC.sent_time ) as email_last_notify_on')
             ->where('S.to_subscription >=', $now)
             ->where('S.to_subscription <=', $last30days)
             ->where('S.isactive', 1)
diff --git a/app/Models/NotificationModel.php b/app/Models/NotificationModel.php
index 18fd6de0..bbddc83d 100755
--- a/app/Models/NotificationModel.php
+++ b/app/Models/NotificationModel.php
@@ -318,12 +318,14 @@ public function customerGroupQueryExecution($queries){
         return count($arr)>0 ? $arr : [];
         
     }
-    public function checkEmailAlreadyExisting($email,$customerId){
+    public function checkAlreadyExistingInHistory($email,$customerId,$subscriptionId){
         return $this->db->table('notification_history_children as nhc' )
         ->join('customers as C', 'C.customer_id = nhc.customer_id', 'left')
+        ->join('subscription as S', 'S.sub_id = nhc.subscription_id', 'left')
         ->where('nhc.receiving_entity =',$email)
         ->where('C.customer_id =',$customerId)
-        ->where('nhc.sent_time >=', date('Y-m-d H:i:s', strtotime('-30 days')))
+        ->where('S.sub_id =',$subscriptionId)
+        ->where('nhc.sent_time >=', date('Y-m-d', strtotime('-30 days')))
         ->get()->getResultArray();
     }
     
diff --git a/app/Models/SubscriptionModel.php b/app/Models/SubscriptionModel.php
index 139e4fda..909b36ee 100755
--- a/app/Models/SubscriptionModel.php
+++ b/app/Models/SubscriptionModel.php
@@ -250,8 +250,7 @@ public function getQueryforSubscriptionDetailsBySchemeName($flag,$condition, $va
         $result = $query->getResultArray();
          $lastQuery = $this->db->getLastQuery();
     $finalQueryString = $lastQuery->getQuery();
-    echo $finalQueryString;
-    die;
+    
         return $result;
     }
     public function getSubscriptionDetailsBySchemeName($selectedScheme, $downloadType){
diff --git a/app/Views/dashboard.php b/app/Views/dashboard.php
index 67e55684..5eb28e12 100755
--- a/app/Views/dashboard.php
+++ b/app/Views/dashboard.php
@@ -108,14 +108,21 @@
                                     </p>
                                 </div> -->
                                 <div class="media-body text-center align-self-center">
-                                    <h3 class="mt-0 mb-1"><?= $a['activeoverall']; ?></h3>
+                                    <h3 class="mt-0 mb-1"><?= $a['overall']; ?></h3>
                                     <p class="text-muted mb-0">Total Subscriber</p>
                                 </div>
                             </div>
                             <br>
-                            <div class="text-success">
-                                <span class="float-left"> New : <span data-toggle="tooltip" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Active New Subscriber" data-plugin="counterup"><?= $a['nonrenewal']; ?></span><br></span>
-                                <span class="float-right"> Renewed: <span data-toggle="tooltip" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Active Re-Newed Subscriber" data-plugin="counterup"><?= $a['renewal']; ?></span><br></span>
+                            <div class="row text-center mt-0">
+                                            <div class="col-md-4">
+                                                <p class="text-muted mb-0"><span class="text-success" data-toggle="tooltip" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="New Subscriber"> New : <?= $a['active']; ?></span> </p>
+                                            </div>
+                                            <div class="col-md-4">
+                                                <p class="text-muted mb-0"><span class="text-warning" data-toggle="tooltip" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Expired Subscriber"> Expired : <?= $a['expired']; ?></span> </p>
+                                            </div>
+                                            <div class="col-md-4">
+                                                <p class="text-muted mb-0"><span class="text-primary" data-toggle="tooltip" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Re-Newed Subscriber"> Renewed : <?= $a['renew']; ?></span> </p>
+                                            </div>
                             </div>
                         </div>
                     </div>
@@ -143,6 +150,7 @@
             <th style="width: 50%;">Scheme Name</th>
             <th style="width: 25%;">Expiring In</th>
             <th style="width: 25%;">Notification On</th>
+            <th style="display: none;">member id</th>
         </tr>
     </thead>
     <tbody>
@@ -169,6 +177,7 @@
                             : ''; 
                         ?>
                     </td>
+                    <td style="display: none;"><?= $e['membership_id']; ?></td>
                 </tr>
             <?php endforeach;  
         else : ?>
diff --git a/app/Views/invoice_form.php b/app/Views/invoice_form.php
index 8a744bb9..18c138a9 100755
--- a/app/Views/invoice_form.php
+++ b/app/Views/invoice_form.php
@@ -1555,18 +1555,21 @@ if (isset($invoice_item_details[0]['to_subscription']) && !empty($invoice_item_d
             },
             success: function(response) {
                 cm = response['data']['customer_membership'];
+                console.log(cm);
                 cm.sort(function(a, b) {
                     return b.is_renew - a.is_renew;
                 });
                 if (cm.length > 0) {
-                    text1 = cm[0].is_renew == 1 ? " - Renewal" : "";
-                    text2 = cm[0].isactive == 0 ? " - Expried" : "";
-                    $(".subscribedetails").show(); // Change this line to use the class selector
-                    let message = "Earlier Membership : " + cm[0].title + " ( From: " + cm[0].formatted_from_subscription + " To: " + cm[0].formatted_to_subscription + " )" + text1 + text2;
-                    console.log(text1);
-                    // $("#schemeName").text(message);
-                    showAlert(message)
-                } else {
+                        $(".subscribedetails").show(); 
+                        let messages = "Earlier Membership : <br>"; 
+                        for (let i = 0; i < cm.length; i++) {
+                            let text1 = cm[i].is_renew == 1 ? " - Renewal" : "";
+                            let text2 = cm[i].isactive == 1 ? " - Active" : " - Draft ";
+                            messages += cm[i].title + "<br> ( From: " + cm[i].formatted_from_subscription + " To: " + cm[i].formatted_to_subscription + " )" + text1 + text2 + " <br>";
+                        }
+                        showAlert(messages.trim());
+                }
+                 else {
                     $(".subscribedetails").show(); // Change this line to use the class selector
                     let message = "No Earlier Membership found";
                     //$("#schemeName").text(message);
@@ -1582,7 +1585,7 @@ if (isset($invoice_item_details[0]['to_subscription']) && !empty($invoice_item_d
     // New function to create a cutom alert box,
     // since the default alert box is small to display the message
     function showAlert(message) {
-    $('#customAlertMessage').text(message); 
+    $('#customAlertMessage').html(message); 
     $('#customAlertModal').modal('show'); 
 }
 
diff --git a/app/Views/notify_the_expiry_subscribers.php b/app/Views/notify_the_expiry_subscribers.php
index 257da56b..039e52d3 100755
--- a/app/Views/notify_the_expiry_subscribers.php
+++ b/app/Views/notify_the_expiry_subscribers.php
@@ -25,7 +25,7 @@
     function sendsms(){
         var params = $("#params").val();
         
-        if(params && params > 0){
+        if(params){
             $.ajax({
                 type: "GET",
                 url: "<?= base_url() . 'getExpCustomerDetail/'?>"+params,