diff --git a/app/Models/HomeModel.php b/app/Models/HomeModel.php
index 46452fe1..59ee8a89 100755
--- a/app/Models/HomeModel.php
+++ b/app/Models/HomeModel.php
@@ -199,7 +199,7 @@ class HomeModel extends Model
                       DATEDIFF(S.to_subscription, CURDATE()) as countdays, 
                       DATE_FORMAT(S.to_subscription, "%d/%m/%Y") as to_subscription_date_format,
                       S.is_renew,
-                      ( NHC.sent_time ) as email_last_notify_on,(select is_renew from subscription as sub where S.sub_id = sub.is_renew LIMIT 1)as renewed')
+                      MAX( NHC.sent_time ) as email_last_notify_on,(select is_renew from subscription as sub where S.sub_id = sub.is_renew LIMIT 1)as renewed')
             ->where('S.to_subscription >=', $past30days)
             ->where('S.to_subscription <=', $last30days)
             ->where('S.isactive', 1)