diff --git a/app/Controllers/TicketServiceController.php b/app/Controllers/TicketServiceController.php
index 219bb9cc..d2265378 100644
--- a/app/Controllers/TicketServiceController.php
+++ b/app/Controllers/TicketServiceController.php
@@ -1669,7 +1669,7 @@ class TicketServiceController extends BaseController
             'emp_code'               => $db_data['emp_code'] ?? null,
             'tpa_no'                 => $excel_tpa_id_data ?? $db_data['tpa_no'] ?? null,
             'emp_name'               => $db_data['emp_name'] ?? null,
-            'relationship'           => $excel_relationship_data ?? null,
+            'relationship'           => strtolower($excel_relationship_data) ?? null,
             'emp_mobile'             => $excel_emp_mobile_data ?? $db_data['emp_mobile'] ?? null,
             'emp_mail'               => $excel_emp_email_data ?? $db_data['emp_mail'] ?? null,