diff --git a/app/Controllers/ThzController.php b/app/Controllers/ThzController.php
index 87d7f2bc..564cde2a 100644
--- a/app/Controllers/ThzController.php
+++ b/app/Controllers/ThzController.php
@@ -363,7 +363,11 @@ class ThzController extends BaseController
 
     private function sendEmail( $templateName, $data , $to_email , $ticketId){
         
-        $mail    =  $this->ticketMailTemplateModel->where('template_name',$templateName )->findAll();
+        $mail    =  $this->ticketMailTemplateModel->where('template_name',$templateName )->findAll()[0] ?? [];
+
+        if(empty($mail)){
+            return ;
+        }
 
         $mail['subject'] = str_replace('%subject%', $data['subject'] ?? '', $mail['subject']);