diff --git a/app/Controllers/ThzController.php b/app/Controllers/ThzController.php
index ba25efb8..093d6b2c 100644
--- a/app/Controllers/ThzController.php
+++ b/app/Controllers/ThzController.php
@@ -272,9 +272,9 @@ class ThzController extends BaseController
 
         $data['subject'] = $this->findSubject($data['thz_id']);
 
-        $assignee_id = $this->findAssigneeId($data['thz_id']) ;
+        $assignee_id    = $this->findAssigneeId($data['thz_id']) ;
 
-        $user_email  = $data['email'] ?? '';
+        $user_email     =  $this->findUserEmail($data['thz_id']) ;
         
         $assignee_email = $this->findAssigneeEmail($assignee_id) ?? '';
 
@@ -310,6 +310,12 @@ class ThzController extends BaseController
         return $assigneeId ? $assigneeId : 0 ;
     }
 
+    private function findUserEmail($ticket_id){
+        $row = $this->thzMasterModel->where('thz_id', $ticket_id)->get()->getRow();
+        $email = $row ? $row->email : null;
+        return $email ? $email : " " ;
+    }
+
     private function findSubject($ticketId){
         $row = $this->thzMasterModel->where('thz_id', $ticketId)->get()->getRow();
         $subject = $row ? $row->subject : null;