diff --git a/app/Libraries/RuleImportService.php b/app/Libraries/RuleImportService.php
index ff0f5fe5..cebc2e9f 100644
--- a/app/Libraries/RuleImportService.php
+++ b/app/Libraries/RuleImportService.php
@@ -903,11 +903,15 @@ class RuleImportService
         //rule_e07f52d4366a2_32_oct2025_3_com
 
         $conditions = $this->buildConditions($rowData);
-        $temp_rule_id .= '_'.$this->incomingData['id'].'_'. strtolower(date('MY')).'_'.(count($conditions));
+        // $temp_rule_id .= '_'.$this->incomingData['id'].'_'. strtolower(date('MY')).'_'.(count($conditions));
+        $monthFormatted = strtoupper(date('M', strtotime($this->incomingData['commission_month']))) 
+                . date('Y', strtotime($this->incomingData['commission_month']));
+
+        $temp_rule_id .= '_'.$this->incomingData['id'].'_'.$monthFormatted;
         $calculation = $this->buildCalculation($rowData);
 
 
-        $temp_rule_id .= '_'.substr($calculation['type'], 0, 3);
+        // $temp_rule_id .= '_'.substr($calculation['type'], 0, 3);
 
         $rule = [
             'id' => $temp_rule_id,