diff --git a/app/Controllers/RestAuthenticationController.php b/app/Controllers/RestAuthenticationController.php
index 3723659..7f7aba7 100755
--- a/app/Controllers/RestAuthenticationController.php
+++ b/app/Controllers/RestAuthenticationController.php
@@ -179,7 +179,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
             $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - verifyEmployeeWithMobileNumber: Exception: " . $th->getMessage() . " --- Line: " . $th->getLine() . " --- Trace: " . $th->getTraceAsString());
             log_message('error', '  ');
             log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => $th],500);
+            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => "", 'message' => $th],500);
         }
     }
 
@@ -323,7 +323,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
             log_message('error', '  ');
             log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
             $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - verifyEmployeeWithEmailId: Exception: " . $th->getMessage() . " --- Line: " . $th->getLine() .  " --- Trace: " . $th->getTraceAsString());
-            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed', 'code' => 500, 'data' => $th], 500);
+            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed', 'code' => 500, 'data' => "", 'message' => $th], 500);
         }
     }
 
@@ -357,7 +357,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
                     $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - getVerifiedUserData: empdata is empty");
                     log_message('error', '  ');
                     log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-                    return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 404,'data' => []],200);                
+                    return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 404,'data' => "", 'message' => "No data found"],200);                
                 }
 
                 $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - getVerifiedUserData: empdata = " . json_encode($empdata));
@@ -447,14 +447,15 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
                 log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
                 // Call the third-party API function
                 $apiResponse = $this->callThirdPartyAPI($requestData,'getVerifiedUserData');
-                return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 404,'data' => [] , 'post_enrollment'=> json_decode($apiResponse, true)],200);
+                return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 404,'data' => '' , 'post_enrollment'=> json_decode($apiResponse, true)],200);
 
             }
+
         } catch (\Exception $e) {
             $this->myLogger->logme("error", "Exception: " . $e->getMessage() . " --- Line: " . $e->getLine() . " --- Trace: " . $e->getTraceAsString());
             log_message('error', '  ');
             log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' =>[], 'error' => $e->getMessage()],500);
+            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => "", 'message' => $e->getMessage()],500);
         }
     }
 
@@ -794,7 +795,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
             $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - Exception: " . $th->getMessage() . " --- Line: " . $th->getLine() . " --- Trace: " . $th->getTraceAsString());
             log_message('error', '  ');
             log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => $th],500);
+            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => "", 'message' => $th],500);
         }
     }
 
@@ -903,7 +904,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
             $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - Exception: " . $th->getMessage() . " --- Line: " . $th->getLine() . " --- Trace: " . $th->getTraceAsString());
             log_message('error', '  ');
             log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => $th],500);
+            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => "", 'message' => $th],500);
         }
     }
 
@@ -929,7 +930,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
                 $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - verifyMpin: No employee data found both PRE and POST");
                 log_message('error', '  ');
                 log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-                return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed', 'code'   => 404, 'data' => []], 200);
+                return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed', 'code'   => 404, 'data' => ""], 200);
             }
 
             $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - verifyMpin: empdata = " . json_encode($empdata));
@@ -1023,7 +1024,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
             $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - Exception: " . $e->getMessage() . " --- Line: " . $e->getLine() . " --- Trace: " . $e->getTraceAsString());
             log_message('error', '  ');
             log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed', 'code' => 500, 'data' => $e->getMessage()], 500);
+            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed', 'code' => 500, 'data' => "", 'message' => $e->getMessage()], 500);
             return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed', 'code' => 200, 'post_enrollment' => json_decode($apiResponse, true)], 200);
         }
     }
@@ -1101,7 +1102,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
                 $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - checkMpin: Mpin - Exist");
                 log_message('error', '  ');
                 log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-                return $this->respond(['status' => 'success','code' => 200,'data' => "Mpin - exist" , 'Mpin' =>$employeeData["mpin"], 'is_mpin_skipped' => $employeeData['is_mpin_skipped'], 'is_biometric_enabled' => $employeeData['is_biometric_enabled']],200);
+                return $this->respond(['status' => 'success','code' => 200,'data' => "", 'message' => "Mpin - exist" , 'Mpin' =>$employeeData["mpin"], 'is_mpin_skipped' => $employeeData['is_mpin_skipped'], 'is_biometric_enabled' => $employeeData['is_biometric_enabled']],200);
             } else {
                 $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - checkMpin: Mpin - not found in PRE so call the thirdpartapi to the POST to check the MPIN");
                 log_message('error', '  ');
@@ -1114,7 +1115,7 @@ class RestAuthenticationController extends AdminController
             $this->myLogger->logme("error", "REST-AUTH-CONTROLLER - Exception: " . $e->getMessage() . " --- Line: " . $e->getLine() . " --- Trace: " . $e->getTraceAsString());
             log_message('error', '  ');
             log_message('error', '************************ PRE END ********************************');
-            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => $e->getMessage()],500);
+            return $this->respond(['status' => 'failed','code' => 500,'data' => "", 'message' => $e->getMessage()],500);
         }
     }